Accounting scandals might not get the general public’s consideration like a raid by Homeland Safety, however questions in regards to the high quality of a publicly traded firm’s books is a critical matter. This week, an inside report made public by Hipgnosis Songs Fund, the London-listed firm that performed a significant position in turning music rights right into a secure, engaging asset class, confirmed what some analysts and shareholders had lengthy suspected.
At greatest, the 26-page report by Shot Tower Capital, the agency employed by the corporate’s board of administrators within the wake of a shareholder revolt in October, particulars how the funding advisor, the Merck Mercuriadis-led Hipgnosis Track Administration (HSM), made quite a few missteps in accounting and monetary projections of its huge music rights portfolio that features music by Pink Sizzling Chili Peppers, Shakira and Journey. At worst, the report suggests the funding advisor selected accounting requirements that overstated income, inflated the portfolio’s valuation and — because the board beforehand acknowledged — resulted in bigger charges paid for managing the portfolio. In any case, info launched Thursday presents an unflattering portrait of HSM and its inside operations.
For its half, HSM considers some “features of the report…to be factually inaccurate and deceptive,” the corporate mentioned in a press release on Thursday (Mar. 28). HSM mentioned it obtained the report the night earlier than its launch and can reply to the board “in the end.”
To be clear, Shot Tower didn’t explicitly touch upon the funding advisor’s intent in utilizing sure accounting practices. The info-heavy report provides evaluation, not hypothesis. However the report, a part of the board of administrators’ effort to regain shareholders’ belief, made clear that annual income was “materially” overstated and laid out quite a few examples the place the fund’s numbers didn’t replicate the truth behind its belongings.
Take, for instance, one thing known as proper to revenue (RTI), that are royalties which are paid to the client on the shut of an acquisition. (If the acquisition’s efficient date is previous to the time limit, royalties obtained by the vendor after the efficient date are credited to the client.) Usually, the quantity of the RTI is deducted from the acquisition value and isn’t included in annual income figures. Nonetheless, Shot Tower discovered that some RTI income from Hipgnosis acquisitions was counted as annual revenues reasonably than an adjustment within the buy value. Because the board’s Mar. 18 replace famous, together with RTI income with annual income quantities to “double counting.” Misclassifying RTI “considerably” elevated the fund’s revenue in 2021 and 2022, in accordance with the report. In fiscal 2019 and financial 2020, zero and 5.3% of offers had RTI intervals that prolonged for multiple yr. In fiscal 2021 and 2022, these numbers jumped to 43.9% and 60.0%.
RTI additionally got here into play with the proposed sale of a portion of the portfolio to Hipgnosis Songs Capital, a three way partnership of HSM and funding agency Blackstone. The catalog was offered to shareholders as having a web buy value of $424.7 million (together with RTI income of $15.3 million). With pro-forma annual income (PFAR) of $24.1 million, HSM assigned a 17.6x a number of to the proposed sale. However Shot Tower believes the catalog’s a number of ought to have been 14.9x based mostly on larger annual income of $28 million and believed the online sale value ought to have been $416.7 million. Shareholders voted towards the proposed sale in October.
In fiscal 2022, the funding advisor modified the way it accounted for accrued revenues. The fund is required to make estimates on income earned within the interval, reasonably than acknowledge income when the royalties are collected. A brand new strategy, known as “utilization accruals,” calculated accruals “based mostly on anticipated utilization” reasonably than when revenues “are paid to, and processed by, assortment societies, publishers and directors.” Shot Tower famous the adoption of utilization accruals occurred “at a time when RTI income was declining and the Fund might now not increase capital for continued acquisitions.” In different phrases, an absence of contemporary funding halted acquisitions and lowered the quantity of RTI income added to annual income. With out the change, Shot Tower believes the fund “would have breached its lender covenants” and financial 2022 income would have been $36 million decrease.
Accrued income additionally triggered issues with PFAR, a non-IFRS metric meant to indicate buyers natural development excluding accruals and RTI. However Shot Tower discovered PFAR did certainly embrace accrual estimates of revenue anticipated to be included within the interval, which “presents an image of natural development that’s larger than development prompt by the assertion knowledge,” in accordance with the report. As such, Shot Tower warned buyers to not depend on PFAR as a metric.
Extra points arose in Shot Tower’s due diligence investigations into how particular person catalogs have been valued. Your complete portfolio, which stood at $2.8 billion on Mar. 31, 2023, is as an alternative value $1.95 billion, in accordance with the report — a distinction of some $850 million. Given the transparency into the fund’s accounting practices, nonetheless, shareholders have been unfazed by the demotion. On Thursday, Hipgnosis Track Fund’s share value jumped 8.3% to 69 pence, its highest closing value since Jan. 31 and 30.4% above its low level in 2024, 52.9 pence, set on Mar. 4. Whether or not the share value will enhance additional might depend upon how shareholders view the board’s response to this report.
Supply hyperlink